I’ve been called “a giant faggot” but I’m medium at most. ♥️

  • 8 Posts
  • 168 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 10th, 2023

help-circle
  • It is not “pointless nitpicking”. It is very important holding fast against allowing very determined forces of hate any foothold whatever.

    I argue 3 things:

    1. Irrespective the truth value of your claim you should not forward that position as there are forces of oppression who will latch onto any conceit of inherent differences between cis and trans people and claim that is the oh-so-important difference around which they claim the need to organize the oppression they are rabidly looking for excuses for
    2. Your claim is not true under the commonly understood nor scientific consensus of what “sex” is
    3. Even under your claim—which I consider simplistic and reductive—that sex is mere reproductive capability via sperm or eggs your assertion remains false

    although it can be lost

    No one “in casual conversation” considers someone “sexless” when they lose their gonads to cancer, nor do you know the “sex” of anyone to whose sex you have referred in going on high-90s percent of cases by your ridiculously narrow definition—I can’t imagine in those cases where you find yourself considering using either term you jam the person with a needle or jerk them off into a cup and bust out a microscope to check motility.

    Finally I’m not sure what you hope to gain by your pedantry—they’re never gonna let you into the car.





  • So rather than defending what you purport to be a valid use you’re just going to attempt to leverage social rejection by implying no one else holds the same opinion I do?

    That supposed to make me feel bad and lead to my changing my position?

    It won’t.

    Every single person on the planet save me could have to opposite view I dol that would just mean everyone else but me is wrong.

    Until either I acquiesce to “beg” meaning “raise” or I die “beg” as in “prompt” will remain an incorrect usage because there will be someone holding the line saying “This far and no farther.”

    Since you don’t appear interested in arguing FOR the meaning you claim the phrase should (and does not) have, I hope you’re prepared to kill me.

    The rhetorical equivalent of pointing and laughing won’t get you what you want.

    Begging the question means something. It does not mean something else.




  • Wait till you hear about the two different uses of the word “literally”.

    “literally” doesn’t mean “figuratively” either. Showing another mistake is not proving any point you think it is.

    Language evolves.

    And individuals which are eaten do not contribute to future evolution.

    I view it has by duty to stop the reproduction of errors around “begs the question” and so long as I am around to fight it “begs the question” is not a synonym for “raises” or “prompts” the question.

    You’re damn right it evolves and I am an evolutionary pressure.



  • FfaerieOxide@kbin.socialtoFunny@kbin.socialTop comment
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    7 months ago

    Lemmy users finding out phrases can have multiple meanings

    One, I don’t use fucking lemmy, and two there is a difference between “multiple meanings” and “incorrect meanings”.

    “Begs the question” means something and misusing the phrase destroys that meaning.