• 2 Posts
  • 1.64K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 29th, 2023

help-circle











  • Oh yeah ironically I think the lectures are even more important to do the story justice in a filmed medium. The comic keeps demanding you turn your brain on but people resist that in movies and movies (and tv) struggle to get people interacting critically with themes. The movie’s cultural impact was politically confused when you could do a voice over of him explaining anarchism during one of the scenes, a montage, or broken up throughout the “The Land of Do-As-You-Please” section of the story or in Evie’s lessons.

    I don’t think it would’ve been super popular among audiences or the production company, but it would’ve been really hammering in the themes and points that the comic was appropriately heavy handed with.




  • I highly recommend it. I never saw the movie but I’ve heard the differences described as the movie is about the bush administration vs the anti war movement while the book is a very British story about British fascism vs British anarchism. It’s not afraid to acknowledge the diversity of victims of fascism and it’s not afraid to call fascists losers with weird relationships to sex (sex is a major theme of the book).

    Alan Moore is a master of his craft, and his craft is left wing comics. There’s a reason a large portion of left wing men are die hards about Watchmen. Vandetta is clearly his first big project, but it hits like a truck and has scenes that stick with you.

    It’s definitely a book to be aware of political and literary themes in. It’s not a story about a noble hero fighting powerful villains. It’s a story about someone who’s been psychologically broken taking revenge because his fellow victims can’t, against weird evil freaks like goebbels, as he tries to help someone who grew up in this world.

    Also Moore’s forward provided helpful context


  • It’s V for Vandetta. Spoilers ahead

    Tap for spoiler

    The man with the dolls is Lewis Prothero, the primary propagandist of the fascist government and former commander of the concentration camp that V was a resident of. This scene ends with him traumatized to the point of institutionalization. This is one of the running themes of the book where insanity is a byproduct of actually understanding the camps for what they were.

    But yeah highly recommend reading the comics. It’s a really good take for a series from the 80s exploring what British fascism would look like.