TLDR: I feel like I wasted a day of my life over the Hue terms and conditions change, and am not convinced that the terms & conditions change panic was worth my time (…and I still “lost”, as I gave in to it). Perhaps you can commiserate with my frustration, or if you’re feeling charitable, tell me what I’m doing wrong.
Long story: Like many of you, I own & operate about a dozen Hue light bulbs, and for many years. Unlike many of you, I am completely new to home assistant; I’ve never used it before. But, reading about the terms & conditions change for Philips Hue, I bought into the hyperbole, and decided I would do something about it.
I bought a Sonoff “P” zigbee dongle, and plugged it into my Unraid server. I set up Home Assistant (first in Docker, then in VM). I tried zigbee2mqtt and/or ZHA back-and-forth several times.
This stuff is NOT user-friendly. Home Assistant wasn’t a terrible experience; it is confusing, but it found & behaved well with most of the stuff in my house… except for those damn light bulbs. Perhaps I’m merely mediocre for this community, but I am easily the most technically savvy person I know in real life, and this was an exercise in frustration just for a dozen light bulbs.
Neither z2m nor zha was ever as good as the Philips hub. Maybe it was my dongle, or the extension cable, or a myriad of other variables I never had to consider with the Philips hub. ZHA was much easier to setup, but it was SLOW, requiring 4 full seconds to change a bulb 10 feet away, and that was when it worked. z2m never found all my bulbs, though its setup was so user-unfriendly it’s possible I was doing something wrong. I don’t think I ever got either system fully set up how I wanted it to be, and I just gave up after hours and hours of frustration. Because my wife expects this stuff to “just work,” I reluctantly went back to the Hue hub and… I had everything reconnected and restored in under an hour. And then, I laughed till I cried–setting up the Philips Hub in home assistant took 10 seconds.
There’s probably a better community than this for my frustration–as it’s not with HA but rather the light bulbs–but perhaps this community can tell me what I’m doing wrong. The idea of a fancy dongle to control my light bulbs without giving in to “the man” is still tempting, but it really needs to just work.
Keep using the hue hub, don’t give it internet access, don’t use the hue app (as that is what will break soon, if I understand correctly). There’s even a paid android app that’s superior to the original app. Unless you want more Zigbee devices, the hue hub bridged into HA should work perfectly fine.
Otherwise, I also have the conbee stick, and Z2M (never used ZHA, had issues with Deconz before I switched), and no issues whatsoever, changes are instant.
Question: While Z2M looks weird, what did you find user-unfriendly about the pairing process? Turning on join mode is pretty straightforward, and then I could just reset the bulbs, and they’d join.
I had trouble resetting the bulbs. Pairing seemed random, though perhaps that’s because resetting was random. Also, the need for an mqtt broker was not intuitive. Overall, the entire process was more complicated than ZHA.
P.s. what is that paid android app??
Resetting bulbs is a hue feature, that doesn’t even require a hub at all. They should blink once reset and then, for me, they always joined Z2M right away.
Yeah, I guess that can be weird, I had one anyway for other stuff ;)
https://hueessentials.com/
It even works with Deconz, but not ZHA or Z2M
I looked online and resetting the bulbs seemed to require a special dimmer switch or something? It doesn’t appear to be possible with just the bulb.
Yeah, but that’s again a pure Hue thing, not related to ZHA, Z2M or anything. Competitor bulbs can be reset by turning them on and off in a pattern, Hue requires you to buy an extra device. If you don’t have one, I’m not sure how you managed to add them to Z2M at all?
Well, yeah. Maybe that was part of the problem? I don’t know.