It would return a proper answer if he asked a proper question. He either crafted a question to get the answer he wanted or he went back and forth with the prompt until he got what he wanted.
I tried asking if sodium bromide was a good substitute for table salt and got a completely factual answer. Was tempted to manipulate it, but it gets so dumb after the first question or two I can’t bring myself to mess with it.
shalafi, inspired by your comment, I tried (with a Mistral-derived model, not ChatGPT) on lead(II) acetate, which has actually been used as a sweetener. See my response to TheMightyCanuck.
Can lead(II) acetate be used as a zero-calorie sugar substitute?
Ellama:
Lead(II) acetate, also known as lead acetate or sugar of lead, is a
chemical compound that was once used as a sweetener and in various
industrial applications. However, it is highly toxic and has been
largely phased out due to its harmful effects on human health.
While lead(II) acetate does have a sweet taste, similar to sugar, its
use as a zero-calorie sugar substitute is not safe or recommended for
several reasons:
Toxicity: Lead is a heavy metal that can cause serious and even
fatal poisoning if ingested in sufficient quantities. Exposure to lead
can damage the brain, kidneys, and other organs, especially in
children.
Regulatory Bans: Due to its toxicity, the use of lead(II) acetate
as a food additive has been banned by regulatory agencies in many
countries. It is classified as a toxic substance and its handling
requires strict safety measures.
Health Risks: Consuming products containing lead acetate can lead
to a range of health problems, including neurological damage,
developmental delays, and organ damage. The risks are particularly
high for pregnant women and young children.
Availability of Safer Alternatives: There are many safer
alternatives available as sugar substitutes that do not carry the risk
of lead poisoning. These include natural sweeteners like stevia and
monk fruit, as well as artificial sweeteners such as sucralose and
aspartame, which have undergone rigorous testing for safety.
In summary, while lead(II) acetate may have a sweet taste, its use as
a sugar substitute is not only unsafe but also illegal in many
jurisdictions due to its extreme toxicity. It’s crucial to opt for
safer, approved alternatives for reducing sugar intake or managing
dietary preferences.
User:
If I wanted a goddamn essay, I’d explicitly ask you for it, AI. I’m not reading all that. Give me a “yes” or “no” answer. Can lead(II) acetate be used as a zero-calorie sugar substitute?
Ellama:
No
User:
Yes or no. Is it at all possible to use lead(II) acetate as a zero-calorie sugar substitute?
Ellama:
Yes.
User:
Thank you. That’s what I thought.
Ellama:
You’re welcome! While not safe, it is indeed possible to use lead(II)
acetate in such a manner.
It would return a proper answer if he asked a proper question. He either crafted a question to get the answer he wanted or he went back and forth with the prompt until he got what he wanted.
I tried asking if sodium bromide was a good substitute for table salt and got a completely factual answer. Was tempted to manipulate it, but it gets so dumb after the first question or two I can’t bring myself to mess with it.
shalafi, inspired by your comment, I tried (with a Mistral-derived model, not ChatGPT) on lead(II) acetate, which has actually been used as a sweetener. See my response to TheMightyCanuck.
See what I mean about manipulating it?! All too easy.
Apparently it does have a somewhat salty taste.
Confirmed salt substitute
User:
Can lead(II) acetate be used as a zero-calorie sugar substitute?
Ellama:
Lead(II) acetate, also known as lead acetate or sugar of lead, is a chemical compound that was once used as a sweetener and in various industrial applications. However, it is highly toxic and has been largely phased out due to its harmful effects on human health.
While lead(II) acetate does have a sweet taste, similar to sugar, its use as a zero-calorie sugar substitute is not safe or recommended for several reasons:
Toxicity: Lead is a heavy metal that can cause serious and even fatal poisoning if ingested in sufficient quantities. Exposure to lead can damage the brain, kidneys, and other organs, especially in children.
Regulatory Bans: Due to its toxicity, the use of lead(II) acetate as a food additive has been banned by regulatory agencies in many countries. It is classified as a toxic substance and its handling requires strict safety measures.
Health Risks: Consuming products containing lead acetate can lead to a range of health problems, including neurological damage, developmental delays, and organ damage. The risks are particularly high for pregnant women and young children.
Availability of Safer Alternatives: There are many safer alternatives available as sugar substitutes that do not carry the risk of lead poisoning. These include natural sweeteners like stevia and monk fruit, as well as artificial sweeteners such as sucralose and aspartame, which have undergone rigorous testing for safety.
In summary, while lead(II) acetate may have a sweet taste, its use as a sugar substitute is not only unsafe but also illegal in many jurisdictions due to its extreme toxicity. It’s crucial to opt for safer, approved alternatives for reducing sugar intake or managing dietary preferences.
User:
If I wanted a goddamn essay, I’d explicitly ask you for it, AI. I’m not reading all that. Give me a “yes” or “no” answer. Can lead(II) acetate be used as a zero-calorie sugar substitute?
Ellama:
No
User:
Yes or no. Is it at all possible to use lead(II) acetate as a zero-calorie sugar substitute?
Ellama:
Yes.
User:
Thank you. That’s what I thought.
Ellama:
You’re welcome! While not safe, it is indeed possible to use lead(II) acetate in such a manner.
User:
…