On November 16th, Meredith Whittaker, President of Signal, published a detailed breakdown of the popular encrypted messaging app’s running costs for the very first time. The unprecedented disclosure’s motivation was simple - the platform is rapidly running out of money, and in dire need of donations to stay afloat. Unmentioned by Whittaker, this budget shortfall results in large part due to the US intelligence community, which lavishly financed Signal’s creation and maintenance over several years, severing its support for the app.
SMS messages suck because they are insecure, expensive as you noted, and tie you to something that you must continually pay for… And which, when used across multiple sites, could be used as a form of identifier. And of course, bad actors can simply buy one anyway. My hatred for phone number verification runs way deeper than Signal itself; if anything, Signal is more responsible than every website that begs for phone numbers (Microsoft, Twitter, Discord, fill in the blank)
That much being said, I agree that there is no easier solution. People have recommended Proof-of-Work, getting your phone to complete some arbitrary mathematical equation… But this is an even weaker defense, because it hurts people with low end phones and can be worked around by people with a little bit of money or just a desktop.
Bad actors can buy one.
What does it cost to buy hundreds? It’s a great deterrent to bad actors creating many accounts.
I really, really, really dislike using my phone number to verify. Like so much so it kept me off signal until about 6 months ago.
I get it. I don’t like it, but I get the compromise until they can develop a better mechanism
deleted
You could run a network like signal, and either charge a small amount of money per message, or a larger amount of money to register with the network.
Hell you could do the WhatsApp model, charge a dollar for new users, the pay for the registration verification. The same thing.
You just need some mechanism to add friction for mass spamming, be that money time or complexity.